Hunza Matters by Hermann Kreutzmann: A Scholarly Bridge from the Silk Road to CPEC
This English review is based on Hermann Kreutzmann's original work and adapts themes from an article originally published in Urdu on my blog, Diverse Dreams.
Introductory Remarks
We often celebrate the Hunza Valley for its breathtaking beauty, but its deeper significance lies in its role as a historical and contemporary crossroads. Hermann Kreutzmann’s Hunza Matters (2020) masterfully shifts the focus from picturesque views to the valley’s critical function as a borderland. This review explores Kreutzmann’s analysis of how Hunza’s past on the ancient Silk Road shapes its present challenges and opportunities, particularly through modern initiatives like the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC). The book provides a scholarly foundation for understanding the very issues-connectivity, culture, and climate-that resonate deeply with local narration.
· Author: Hermann Kreutzmann
· Publication Year: 2020
· Publisher: Routledge
· Number of Pages: 570
About the Author
Hermann Kreutzmann is a renowned German geographer and a leading expert on High Asia.For decades, his research has focused on the social, economic, and political geography of mountain regions, including the Pamirs, Karakoram, and Hindu Kush. His extensive fieldwork establishes him as an authoritative voice on the region.
Literary Contribution:
Over 30 years of research on the Northern Areas of Pakistan (Kreutzmann, 2020).
· Authorship of more than 10 standard academic books.
· Over 100 research papers in international journals.
The Core of the Book: Beyond the Scenery
Kreutzmann's book is structured to build a comprehensive understanding. It begins by challenging romanticized views of Hunza, framing it instead as a strategic borderland. Subsequent chapters delve into its history as a Silk Road nexus, its environmental vulnerabilities, economic transformations, and political evolution. The final sections analyze modern infrastructure projects and future prospects, firmly grounding the discussion in the concept of "bordering and ordering."
Review of Core Themes in Hunza Matters
Here’s a breakdown of the key themes Kreutzmann explores:
1. Historical and Geographical Context:
Kreutzmann establishes that Hunza’s geography dictated its history. Its position on ancient trade routes made it a conduit for goods and cultures, not an isolated enclave. He details how local rulers leveraged this location to negotiate autonomy—a historical precedent that informs Hunza’s modern engagement with state powers and mega-projects like CPEC.
2. Preservation of Cultural Identity:
The book presents cultural traditions like Ginani and Nowruz as dynamic, living practices. Kreutzmann describes crafts such as woodcarving and embroidery as vital to both economy and identity, emphasizing adaptive preservation in the face of globalization and tourism.
3. Environmental Issues:
The author provides a rigorous account of environmental threats, directly linking local hazards—glacial melt, floods—to global climate change. He frames this as a pressing issue of climate justice, where communities with minimal carbon footprints face severe consequences.
4. Economic Challenges:
The analysis traces the economic shift from agro-pastoralism to an economy increasingly reliant on remittances and tourism. The central challenge identified is harnessing new opportunities while safeguarding local autonomy and sustainable practices.
5. Impact of Tourism:
The book critiques extractive mass tourism, advocating instead for community-based models that ensure benefits remain local and cultural exchanges are respectful.
6. Infrastructure Development: Kreutzmann brilliantly juxtaposes ancient caravan routes with modern highways like the Karakoram Highway and CPEC projects. He demonstrates how infrastructure is a tool for exerting influence and reordering spatial relationships.
Personal Reflection
Engaging with Hunza Matters provided a scholarly backbone to the contemporary issues we often discuss here on Diverse Dreams. Kreutzmann’s research offers a robust academic framework that echoes local concerns about preserving identity amidst rapid change. His work validates the importance of grounding global discussions of development, climate, and connectivity in the specific, lived realities of places like Hunza.
Conclusion
Hunza Matters is an essential work that successfully repositions the valley from a passive scenic wonder to an active player in regional dynamics. Kreutzmann’s interdisciplinary approach provides a powerful lens for understanding the interplay of history, geography, and contemporary forces. While a deeper inclusion of everyday local voices would add further richness, the book is indispensable for anyone seeking to understand Hunza’s true significance in both the ancient and modern worlds.
References
Kreutzmann, H. (2015). Pamirian crossroads: Kirghiz and Wakhi of High Asia. Harrassowitz Verlag.
Kreutzmann,H. (2020). Hunza matters: Bordering and ordering ancient and new Silk Roads. Routledge.
Hunza is the hub of mass economic tourism.
ReplyDeleteThanks dear, you are absolutely right🙏
Delete